This paper presents the methods developed and key findings of the IWEC project performed by Ocean Harvesting Technologies AB (OHT). It aimed to reduce the levelized cost of energy (LCoE) of OHT’s wave energy converter InfinityWEC, by analysing how different key parameters impact cost and annual output using a model of a 100-MW array installation. Component-level cost functions were developed and mapped to key parameters and constraints of the system. A large number of system configurations were then evaluated with a numerically efficient 3 degree-of-freedom (DoF) nonlinear radiationdiffraction model in WEC-Sim along with OHT’s sea statetuned polynomial reactive control (PRC). The most promising configurations were identified and investigated in more detail. The configuration with the best LCoE were finally identified and analysed further, including estimation of the effect of changing the PRC to model predictive control, which resulted in 17-34% higher annual output and 12-23% lower LCoE. The final LCoE was found to be 93-162 EUR MWh at 100 MW installed capacity. An important finding from the study is that using simplified metrics such as CAPEX/ton was found to be irrelevant. Numerical wave tank testing, high-fidelity computational fluid dynamics (CFD), were used to tune the viscous drag of the 3 DoF WEC-Sim model. Applying verification and validation (V&V) techniques the CFD simulations showed a relatively large numerical uncertainty, but the average power and the motion responses were found to be sufficiently accurate.
There are many uncertainties associated with the estimation of extreme loads acting on a wave energy converter (WEC). In this study we perform a sensitivity analysis of extreme loads acting on the Uppsala University (UU) WEC concept. The UU WEC consists of a bottom-mounted linear generator that is connected to a surface buoy with a taut mooring line. The maximum stroke length of the linear generator is enforced by end-stop springs. Initially, a Variation Mode and Effect Analysis (VMEA) was carried out in order to identify the largest input uncertainties. The system was then modeled in the time-domain solver WEC-SIM coupled to the dynamic mooring solver Moody. A sensitivity analysis was made by generating a surrogate model based on polynomial chaos expansions, which rapidly evaluates the maximum loads on the mooring line and the end-stops. The sensitivities are ranked using the Sobol index method. We investigated two sea states using equivalent regular waves (ERW) and irregular wave (IRW) trains. We found that the ERW approach significantly underestimates the maximum loads. Interestingly, the ERW predicted wave height and period as the most important parameters for the maximum mooring tension, whereas the tension in IRW was most sensitive to the drag coefficient of the surface buoy. The end-stop loads were most sensitive to the PTO damping coefficient.
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is becoming an increasingly popular tool in the wave energy sector, and over the last five years we have seen many studies using CFD. While the focus of the CFD studies have been on the validation phase, comparing numerically obtained results against experimental tests, the uncertainties associated with the numerical solution has so far been more or less overlooked. There is a need to increase the reliability of the numerical solutions in order to perform simulation based optimization at early stages of development. In this paper we introduce a well-established verification and validation (V&V) technique. We focus on the solution verification stage and how to estimate spatial discretization errors for simulations where no exact solutions are available. The technique is applied to the cases of a 2D heaving box and a 3D moored cylinder. The uncertainties are typically acceptable with a few percent for the 2D box, while the 3D cylinder case show double digit uncertainties. The uncertainties are discussed with regard to physical features of the flow and numerical techniques.
The design of wave energy converters should rely on numerical models that are able to estimate accurately the dynamics and loads in extreme wave conditions. A high-fidelity CFD model of a 1:30 scale point-absorber is developed and validated on experimental data. This work constitutes beyond the state-of-the-art validation study as the system is subjected to 50-year return period waves. Additionally, a new methodology that addresses the well-known challenge in CFD codes of mesh deformation is successfully applied and validated. The CFD model is evaluated in different conditions: wave-only, free decay, and wave–structure interaction. The results show that the extreme waves and the experimental setup of the wave energy converter are simulated within an accuracy of 2%. The developed high-fidelity model is able to capture the motion of the system and the force in the mooring line under extreme waves with satisfactory accuracy. The deviation between the numerical and corresponding experimental RAOs is lower than 7% for waves with smaller steepness. In higher waves, the deviation increases up to 10% due to the inevitable wave reflections and complex dynamics. The pitch motion presents a larger deviation, however, the pitch is of secondary importance for a point-absorber wave energy converter.
The International Energy Agency Technology Collaboration Program for Ocean Energy Systems (OES) initiated the OES Wave Energy Conversion Modeling Task, which focused on the verification and validation of numerical models for simulating wave energy converters (WECs). The long-term goal is to assess the accuracy of and establish confidence in the use of numerical models used in design as well as power performance assessment of WECs. To establish this confidence, the authors used different existing computational modeling tools to simulate given tasks to identify uncertainties related to simulation methodologies: (i) linear potential flow methods; (ii) weakly nonlinear Froude–Krylov methods; and (iii) fully nonlinear methods (fully nonlinear potential flow and Navier–Stokes models). This article summarizes the code-to-code task and code-to-experiment task that have been performed so far in this project, with a focus on investigating the impact of different levels of nonlinearities in the numerical models. Two different WECs were studied and simulated. The first was a heaving semi-submerged sphere, where free-decay tests and both regular and irregular wave cases were investigated in a code-to-code comparison. The second case was a heaving float corresponding to a physical model tested in a wave tank. We considered radiation, diffraction, and regular wave cases and compared quantities, such as the WEC motion, power output and hydrodynamic loading.
Since time-domain simulations of wave energy converters are computationally expensive, how can we analyse their dynamics and test wide ranges of design variables, without simplifying the physics involved? One possible solution is the use of General Polynomial Chaos (gPC). GPC provides computationally efficient surrogate models for partial differential equation based models, which are particularly useful for sensitivity analysis and uncertainty quantification. We demonstrate the application of gPC to study the dynamics of a wave energy converter in an operational sea-state, when there is uncertainty in the values of the stiffness and damping coefficient of the power take-off.
A numerical model (MOODY) for the study of the dynamics of cables is presented in Palm et al. (2013), which was developed for the design of mooring systems for floating wave energy converters. But how does it behave when it is employed together with the tools used to model floating bodies? To answer this question, MOODY was coupled to a linear potential theory code and to a computational fluid dynamics code (OpenFOAM), to model small scale experiments with a moored buoy in linear waves. The experiments are well reproduced in the simulations, with the exception of second order effects when linear potential theory is used and of the small overestimation of the surge drift when computational fluid dynamics is used. The results suggest that MOODY can be used to successfully model moored floating wave energy converters.
Mooring systems are required to keep floating wave energy converters (WECs) on station. The mooring concept might impact the performance of the WEC, its cost and its integrity. With the aim of clarifying the pros and cons of different mooring designs, we present the results from physical model experiments of three different mooring concepts in regular and irregular waves, including operational and survival conditions. The parameters investigated are the tension in the cables, the motions of the device in the different degrees of freedom and the seabed footprint in each case. We can see that the mooring system affects the performance of the wave energy converter, but the magnitude of the impact depends on the parameter analysed, on the mode of motion studied and on the conditions of the sea. Moreover, different configurations have similar performances in some situations and the choice of one over another might come down to factors such as the type of soil of the seabed, the spacing desired between devices, or environmental impacts. The results of our experiments provide information for a better selection of the mooring system for a wave energy converter when several constraints are taken into account (power production, maximum displacements, extreme tensions, etc).
Until now, wave-energy developers have focused on designing large machines for utility-scale electricity generation. While many concepts with good capture performance have been devised, significant commercial success has yet to be achieved in this market. Smaller wave energy converters (WECs) for specialist uses have received less attention. Emerging applications for these machines include powering sensors for ocean monitoring and providing energy for recharging maritime autonomous vehicles. Small reliable floating WECs can provide both the low levels of power required for these applications, and a surface platform for satellite
communications. Here, the key idea is to reduce costs and increase human safety by deploying small WECs to perform tasks that would otherwise require a ship. Developing small WECs for specialist uses provides a fast route to market, thereby creating a viable financial and technical base for the development of larger devices for applications where more power is required. This paper reports early results of time- and frequency-domain simulations of a compact WEC designed for monitoring the ocean environment.
A generic point-absorbing wave energy converter is modeled in CFD as a vertical cylinder, moored with a single catenary chain that is fully coupled through a dynamic mooring code. The method of choice is very complete and takes much of the non-linearities in the highly coupled system of the moored body into account. The paper presents numerical results compared with experimental data for surge, heave and pitch motion in both decay tests and regular waves. Further, the wave motion response of the cylinder is computed using both a viscous and a non-viscous formulation as a first attempt to quantify viscous effects. Results show a good match between numerical and experimental results in heave, while the surge and pitch motion are more difficult to reproduce. The mooring load cycle appearance compares well with the experiments in shape but gives higher peak values. Although made at low Keulegan-Carpenter numbers, the simulations show vortical structures due to the heave motion, and the resulting motions are clearly affected by the inclusion or exclusion of viscosity. More test-cases and detailed experimental results are needed for further quantification of the viscous impact on floating point absorbers.