This paper summarises the work conducted within the 1st FOWT (Floating Offshore Wind Turbine) Comparative Study organised by the EPSRC (UK) ‘Extreme loading on FOWTs under complex environmental conditions’ and ‘Collaborative computational project on wave structure interaction (CCP-WSI)’ projects. The hydrodynamic response of a FOWT support structure is simulated with a range of numerical models based on potential theory, Morison equation, Navier-Stokes solvers and hybrid methods coupling different flow solvers. A series of load cases including the static equilibrium tests, free decay tests, operational and extreme focused wave cases are considered for the UMaine VolturnUS-S semi-submersible platform, and the results from 17 contributions are analysed and compared with each other and against the experimental data from a 1:70 scale model test performed in the COAST Laboratory Ocean Basin at the University of Plymouth. It is shown that most numerical models can predict similar results for the heave response, but significant discrepancies exist in the prediction of the surge and pitch responses as well as the mooring line loads. For the extreme focused wave case, while both Navier–Stokes and potential flow base models tend to produce larger errors in terms of the root mean squared error than the operational focused wave case, the Navier-Stokes based models generally perform better. Given the fact that variations in the solutions (sometimes large) also present in the results based the same or similar numerical models, e.g., OpenFOAM, the study highlights uncertainties in setting up a numerical model for complex wave structure interaction simulations such as those involving a FOWT and therefore the importance of proper code validation and verification studies.
Accurate prediction of wave transformation is key in the design of coastal and nearshore structures which typically depends on numerical models. Turbulent and rotational effects call for the use of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) solvers of which a large range of formulations including free surface treatments exists. Physical wave flume tests of wave propagation over a submerged bar with various levels of nonlinearity, regularity, and wave-breaking, dedicated to numerical model benchmarking or validation, were carried out in the Ocean and Coastal Engineering Laboratory of Aalborg University. Three fundamentally different CFD models each widespread within their category are benchmarked against the experimental data. The CFD models are based on (i) the Volume of Fluid (VoF) based interFoam solver of OpenFOAM, (ii) the sigma-transformation solver of MIKE 3 Waves Model FM, and (iii) the weakly compressible delta-SPH solver of DualSPHysics. Accuracy of the numerical models is assessed from surface elevation time series, evaluation metrics (averaged errors on surface elevations, amplitudes, phases, and wave set-up), and spectral analyzes to calculate the amplitude and phase contents of primary and higher-order components along the wave flume. Applicability is assessed from computational costs and ease-of-use factors such as the effort to configure the numerical models and achieve convergence. In general, the numerical models have high correlation to the physical tests and are as such suitable to model complex wave transformation with an accuracy sufficient for most coastal engineering applications. The VoF model performs more accurately under the turbulent conditions of breaking waves, increasing its relative accuracy in the prediction of downwave surface elevation. The sigma transformation model has simulation times one to two orders of magnitude lower than those of the VoF and SPH models.
This paper describes a new high-order composite numerical model for simulating moored floating offshore bodies. We focus on a floating offshore wind turbine and its static equilibrium and free decay. The composite scheme models linear to weakly nonlinear motions in the time domain by solving the Cummins equations. Mooring forces are acquired from a discontinuous Galerkin finite element solver. Linear hydrodynamic coefficients are computed by solving a pseudo-impulsive radiation problem in three dimensions using a spectral element method. Numerical simulations of a moored model-scale floating offshore wind turbine were performed and compared with experimental measurements for validation, ultimately showing a fair agreement.
This paper presents a numerical benchmark study of wave propagation due to a paddle motion using different high-fidelity numerical models, which are capable of replicating the nearly actual physical wave tank testing. A full time series of the measured wave generation paddle motion that was used to generate wave propagation in the physical wave tank will be utilized in each of the models contributed by the participants of International Energy Agency Ocean Energy Systems Task 10, which includes both computational fluid dynamics and smoothed particle hydrodynamics models. The high-fidelity simulations of the physical wave test case will allow for the evaluation of the initial transient effects from wave ramp-up and its evolution in the wave tank over time for two representative regular waves with varying levels of nonlinearity. Metrics like the predicted wave surface elevation at select wave probes, wave period, and phase-shift in time will be assessed to evaluate the relative accuracy of numerical models versus experimental data within specified time intervals. These models will serve as a guide for modelers in the wave energy community and provide a base case to allow further and more detailed numerical modeling of the fixed Kramer Sphere Cases under wave excitation force wave tank testing.
Wave excitation tests on a fixed sphere with the center at the still water level were carried out with three different physical wave basin setups. The tests were completed as a continued effort of the working group OES Wave Energy Converters Modeling Verification and Validation to increase confidence in numerical models of wave energy converters by generation of accurate benchmarks datasets for numerical model validation. An idealized test case with wave excitation of a fixed sphere to be used with the benchmarks was formulated. The three investigated physical wave basin setups included: 1) a six degree-of-freedom load cell mounted to the top of the sphere, 2) a bending beam force transducer mounted to the top of the sphere, and 3) a system of six pretensioned wires mounted to the top and bottom of the sphere with force transducers attached to each wire. The aim of the present paper is to identify the best representation of the idealized test case. To this end, the three experimental setups are inter-compared in terms of dynamic properties, sensitivity, and disturbances of the water phase from the presence of measurement equipment. Low inter-experiment variability was disclosed, ie, 5-8% depending on wave-nonlinearity, indicating accurate representations of the idealized test case across all setups. Setup 3 was found to be the more accurate representation and further work with this setup to release a public benchmark dataset was planned.
With increasing demand for renewable energy resources, the development of alternative concepts is still ongoing. The wave energy sector is still in vast development on the way to contribute to the energy production world wide. The present study presents the development of the Exowave wave energy converter made so far. A numerical model has been established supported by wave flume tests performed at Aalborg University during the first phase of the development. Furthermore, a successful open sea demonstration has been performed on 7 meters of water at Blue Accelerator, Belgium, from which the concept has been proven. As part of the ongoing research, verification of the numerical model will be made through experimental testing in the wave tank of Aalborg University, and an open sea demonstration at 14 meters of water depth will be executed off the coast of Hanstholm, Denmark.
Highly accurate and precise heave decay tests on a sphere with a diameter of 300 mm were completed in a meticulously designed test setup in the wave basin in the Ocean and Coastal Engineering Laboratory at Aalborg University, Denmark. The tests were dedicated to providing a rigorous benchmark dataset for numerical model validation. The sphere was ballasted to half submergence, thereby floating with the waterline at the equator when at rest in calm water. Heave decay tests were conducted, in which the sphere was held stationary and dropped from three drop heights: a small drop height, which can be considered a linear case, a moderately nonlinear case, and a highly nonlinear case with a drop height from a position where the whole sphere was initially above the water. The precision of the heave decay time series was calculated from random and systematic standard uncertainties. At a 95% confidence level, uncertainties were found to be very low — on average only about 0.3% of the respective drop heights. Physical parameters of the test setup and associated uncertainties were quantified. A test case was formulated that closely represents the physical tests, enabling the reader to do his/her own numerical tests. The paper includes a comparison of the physical test results to the results from several independent numerical models based on linear potential flow, fully nonlinear potential flow, and the Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes (RANS) equations. A high correlation between physical and numerical test results is shown. The physical test results are very suitable for numerical model validation and are public as a benchmark dataset.
Floating Power Plant is, together with several partners, preparing to design, build and test a scaled version of the complete so-called P80 device. The scaled model is to be tested in AAU's wave basin, SSPA's facilities, followed by at least one external facility. The model will be tested in combinations of wave, wind and current conditions with a view to validating the numerical models and to further develop the understanding of the interactions within the device. The purpose of this document is to gather information that is relevant to designing and building the physically scaled model, and to designing and executing the test campaign.
In a number of experiments and field tests of point absorbers, snap loads have been identified to cause damage on the mooring cables. Snap loads are basically propagating shock waves, which require special care in the numerical modeling of the mooring cable dynamics. In this paper we present a mooring cable model based on a conservative formulation, discretized using the Runge-Kutta discontinuous Galerkin method. The numerical model is thus well suited for correctly capturing snap loads. The numerical model is verified and validated using analytic and experimental data and the computed results are satisfactory.